entries friends calendar user info Previous Previous Next Next
Language Computeer - NSL [for chachachana]
Fists of irony
trochee
trochee
Add to Memories
Share
NSL [for chachachana]
The Beeb has a story about Nicaraguan Sign Language.

[update: it's got the Beeb's usual pigheadedness when it comes to reporting on language issues:

Some people in the extreme "nature" camp believe that grammar is essentially hard-wired in the brain, while those in the extreme "nurture" camp think language has no innate basis and is just culturally transmitted.

It has been difficult to clear up the argument,...

This is so not a good way to frame the "debate". There isn't a debate, you idiots. Nobody's in either of those camps; they're straw men! ... I wish they'd assign somebody who'd taken a class in linguistics -- or rhetoric -- to do this reporting.

I might add that the Wikipedia article is not at all guilty of this pitiful attempt to sex up the story through weak rhetoric (false dichotomy) and weak reporting "some people believe". Another victory for the worker's paradise of information. ]

Current Mood: should be working
Current Music: Interpol

Comments
solri From: solri Date: September 17th, 2004 10:52 pm (UTC) (Link)
Nobody's in either of those camps; they're straw men!

Well said.
1 comment or Leave a comment
profile
love, play & inquiry
User: trochee
Name: love, play & inquiry
calendar
Back April 2013
123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930
links
page summary
tags